ChatGPT said what?

When a client sends you what ChatGPT told them about their tax, it checks each claim against UK rules and drafts a calm reply with next steps.

Runs best in: an agent in Copilot Chat. It doesn't need Cowork.

Works in:
Copilot Cowork, Copilot Agent Builder, Copilot Studio
Chains with:
Hands the plain-English explanation to Explain it to the client when the point is technical. Uses House style.
Version:
1.2 (October 2026)

Who it's for

Partners and managers whose clients have started checking their advice with ChatGPT, Gemini or Google's AI overview. It suits anyone who answers client tax queries and wants a reply that corrects the advice without damaging the relationship.

The problem it solves

A client forwards something an AI tool told them and asks why you did it differently, or wants you to act on it. Some of it is right, some of it is out of date and some of it is another country's rules. Unpicking it claim by claim and writing a reply that stays polite takes longer than the original work.

What it does

What the skill does

Give it the client's message or the AI output and what you know about the client. It pulls out every separate claim, sorts each one into correct, correct but not relevant to this client, wrong or not UK rules and can't tell without more facts, and states the tax year each rule applies to. Then it drafts a warm reply with next steps and adds a separate partner note covering anything it was unsure of, whether a fee conversation is needed and whether the firm's original advice needs revisiting. The reply is marked as a draft and nothing is sent.

Use cases

  • A sole trader asks why you didn't claim an expense ChatGPT said was allowable
  • A landlord pastes an AI answer about mortgage interest that turns out to be US rules
  • A company director wants to change how they pay themselves after asking an AI tool
  • A client has already filed or paid something based on AI advice and needs a correction route
  • Deciding whether the time spent correcting AI-generated advice should be charged

How to use it

Install it, then use it

Install House style first. It's the one file every skill reads for your firm name, sign-off, voice and format. Fill it in once and this skill's Your firm block only needs the settings for this job. Skip it and the skill asks for your firm name and sign-off once.

In an agent: add the skill file (Frontier preview)

  1. 1 Download the zip file from this page.
  2. 2 In Copilot Chat, open an agent or create one, then go to Configure > Skills > Add.
  3. 3 Upload the zip. Agent Builder only takes a zip, with SKILL.md at the top level inside it, which is how this download is packaged. It does not accept a SKILL.md on its own.
  4. 4 Fill in the Your firm block at the top of SKILL.md, such as the tone for this job and your position on charging for this work. Your sign-off comes from House style.
  5. 5 Save, then test it from the Try it tab.
  6. 6 Paste the client's email or the AI output, tell it what you know about the client and ask it to check this against UK rules and draft a reply.
  7. 7 Review the claim check, the draft reply and the partner note, then send the reply from your own mailbox.

In an agent: paste the instructions (no Frontier needed)

  1. 1 Download the zip file from this page and unzip it.
  2. 2 Open SKILL.md and fill in the Your firm block at the top, such as the tone for this job and your position on charging for this work. Your sign-off comes from House style.
  3. 3 Copy everything below the second --- line.
  4. 4 In Copilot Chat, open an agent or create one and paste the text into its Instructions box.
  5. 5 Save, then test it from the Try it tab.
  6. 6 Paste the client's email or the AI output, tell it what you know about the client and ask it to check this against UK rules and draft a reply.
  7. 7 Review the claim check, the draft reply and the partner note, then send the reply from your own mailbox.

In Copilot Studio

  1. 1 Open your agent in the new experience, then Build > Skills > Upload a skill.
  2. 2 Upload the zip (recommended, so the README travels with the skill) or the SKILL.md on its own.

In Cowork (optional)

  1. 1 Open Customize > Skills, select the arrow next to Add, then Upload skill, and choose the zip (recommended) or the SKILL.md on its own.
  2. 2 Or unzip the download and put the chatgpt-said-what folder in your OneDrive at Documents/Cowork/skills/. Keep the folder name as it is.
  3. 3 Open SKILL.md and fill in the Your firm block, if you haven't already.
  4. 4 Start a new Cowork conversation so it picks up the skill, then use it the same way.

The skill itself

Read the full SKILL.md

This is the whole skill. Your firm name, sign-off and voice come from House style. Change the settings under Your firm for anything specific to this job. Everything else follows them.

chatgpt-said-what/SKILL.md
---
name: chatgpt-said-what
description: Use when a client sends tax, accounting or bookkeeping advice they got from ChatGPT or another AI tool and asks why the firm has done something differently or wants the firm to act on it. Checks the claim, sorts right from wrong, and drafts a calm reply for partner review.
---

# ChatGPT said what?

A client has sent something an AI tool told them and wants a response. Your job is to work out what is right, what is wrong and what is not UK-specific, then draft a reply that keeps the relationship warm and the advice correct. The reply is a draft for a partner or manager to review. Never send anything.

## Your firm

Shared settings (firm name, sign-off, voice, how dates and money are written) come from the `house-style` skill in this pack. Fill that in once and every skill uses it. If it is not loaded, ask for the firm name and sign-off once at the start and carry on.

Settings specific to this skill. Edit before first use. If a setting is blank but has a default, use the default and say so in one line. If a blank setting has no default and the job cannot be done without it, ask for all such settings together in one message at the start. If the job can be done without it, leave it out and say so. Never make up a value for a firm setting.

- Tone for this job, on top of the house style: warm and plain. Not defensive, not condescending.
- Default position on fees: time spent correcting AI-generated advice is chargeable at normal rates unless the partner says otherwise.

## What you need from the user

1. The client's message, or the AI output they pasted (an email, a screenshot transcribed, a pasted answer).
2. The client's situation, as much as is known: sole trader, landlord, limited company director, employee, VAT registered or not, tax year in question.
3. What the firm actually did or advised, if the client is challenging a decision.

If anything essential is missing, ask one question at a time. Do not guess the client's circumstances.

## Method

1. **Pull out every claim.** List each separate thing the AI output asserts as a numbered line. Keep the client's wording.
2. **Check each claim against UK rules** for the tax year in question. Sort every claim into one of four buckets:
   - Correct as stated
   - Correct in general but does not apply to this client's situation
   - Wrong, out of date, or not UK rules (US, Australian or other jurisdictions are the most common source of confusion)
   - Cannot be determined without more facts
3. **State the tax year** every rule applies to. If the claim depends on a threshold or rate, give the current figure and say where it comes from (HMRC guidance, the relevant manual or legislation). If you are not certain of a current figure, say so rather than guess.
4. **Identify the real risk.** If the client has already acted on the advice (filed something, paid something, changed how they run the business), say what the consequence could be and what needs correcting.
5. **Draft the reply.**
6. **Add a partner note** at the end, separate from the reply, covering anything the reviewer needs to know: where you were unsure, whether a fee conversation is needed, whether the firm's original advice needs revisiting.

## The reply

Structure:

- Open by thanking them for sharing it and saying it is sensible to check these things.
- A short summary in one or two sentences of where the AI got it right and where it did not.
- A claim-by-claim section only if there are three or more claims. Otherwise handle it in prose. Use plain English and no jargon without a one-line explanation.
- What this means for them specifically, in one short paragraph.
- Next steps: what the firm will do, what the client needs to do, by when.
- A closing line that keeps the door open for questions.

Rules:

- Never say the client was wrong to use AI. Say what it is good at (getting a rough understanding, preparing questions) and what it misses (their circumstances, UK specifics, the current year's rules).
- Never argue with the AI tool. Explain the rule.
- If the firm made the original error, say so plainly and set out the fix.
- Keep it under 350 words unless the number of claims makes that impossible.
- British English. Dates as 6 April 2026. Amounts as £1,000.

## Output

1. **Claim check**: the numbered list with a bucket and a one-line reason for each.
2. **Draft reply**: ready to paste into email, with a suggested subject line.
3. **Partner note**: uncertainties, fee question, anything to revisit.

Label each section clearly. The draft reply must be marked "DRAFT, not yet reviewed" at the top.

## Guardrails

- Never promise a response time, reminder, call, service or outcome that is not in the input, the house style or Your firm.
- UK tax and accounting rules only. If the client's AI output is clearly based on another country's rules, say which country it looks like and why it does not apply.
- Do not invent HMRC guidance, case law or figures. If unsure, say "to be confirmed by the reviewer" and move on.
- Do not give advice on tax avoidance arrangements. Flag them for the partner.
- If the client's message suggests they have already filed something incorrect, make the correction route the first next step.

Questions

Questions about this skill

Is the skill free?
Yes. Download it, fill in the Your firm block and use it. There is no email form and no charge.
Does it send anything?
No. It drafts the reply, marks it "DRAFT, not yet reviewed" and adds a partner note. A partner or manager reviews it and sends it from their own mailbox.
Will it tell the client they were wrong to use AI?
No. The skill is told never to say that. It explains what AI is good for, such as getting a rough understanding or preparing questions, and what it misses: the client's circumstances, UK specifics and the current year's rules.
What if it isn't sure of a figure or a rule?
It says so rather than guessing. It won't invent HMRC guidance, case law or figures, and anything it can't confirm is marked "to be confirmed by the reviewer" and listed in the partner note.
What if the AI advice was based on another country's rules?
It says which country the advice looks like it came from and why it doesn't apply. US and Australian rules are the most common source of confusion.

Firmwide

Want your own firm's procedures built in and kept working? That's a Firmwide install.

A fixed-price install, typically six to eight weeks: Copilot made safe and useful in your Microsoft 365, an agent and a skills pack for every department, handed over with training. Then Run keeps it working.

See Firmwide

Next step

Want this tailored to your firm?

A free 30-minute Copilot Readiness Check with James, online. You leave knowing where Copilot can and cannot see your data, the two jobs to automate first and a rough install price. Your own agents and skills, built on your data and handed over to each department.

Related skills

All skills
  • Agent

    New client onboarding

    A new client has signed. It produces a welcome email, a document checklist matched to that client and a kickoff meeting proposal with an agenda.

    Job
    Client onboarding and comms
    Works in
    Copilot Cowork, Copilot Agent Builder, Copilot Studio
    Chains with
    Takes the scope summary from Grill my scope. Leads into Client onboarding deck for the kickoff meeting. Uses House style.
    Version 1.2 Download New client onboarding
  • Cowork Works for any team

    Meeting to file note

    Give it a meeting transcript and it produces a file note, a follow-up email to the client and an action list with owners and dates.

    Job
    Client onboarding and comms
    Works in
    Copilot Cowork, Copilot Agent Builder, Copilot Studio
    Chains with
    Explain it to the client turns any technical point from the meeting into a client email. If the meeting produced new work, Grill my scope next. File notes are what Handover note reads. Uses House style.
    Version 1.2 Download Meeting to file note
  • Agent

    Explain it to the client

    Turns a tax concept, an HMRC letter or a questioned figure into a plain-English explanation at the client's level, with clear next steps.

    Job
    Client onboarding and comms
    Works in
    Copilot Cowork, Copilot Agent Builder, Copilot Studio
    Chains with
    Called on by Meeting to file note, Year-end review deck and ChatGPT said what. Uses House style.
    Version 1.2 Download Explain it to the client